Maximizing Renewals

I’ve had an unusual amount of questions regarding renewals lately so here goes:

My top tips on maximizing renewals…

Market Knowledge:

As in new leases or renewals, your market knowledge is KEY!! Knowing if: 1. your pizza guy could relo to a nearby center for cheaper rent, or 2. if a neighboring landlord would be willing to turnkey  their pizza place or 3. the neighboring center would be better ingress and egress for 4. the delivery guy or 5. if the location has much better visibility for the brand- is CRUCIALLY important when evaluating the renewal.

Cost to relocate:

If the tenant (think restaurant, salon or medical) 1. has significant infrastructure and it would be very expensive for them to relocate, it’s very important to analyze vs 2. if it’s a cell phone store and they could easily and cheaply relocation.Do you even want this tenant to renew this particular tenant or particular use? Are the tenants’ sales matching your centers’ mix or is it a mismatch? If the tenant is out of options, you don’t HAVE to automatically renew them. Yes, it is more work to find a backfill but our job is to maximize the value of the center and if the use no longer mixes well with the new ten mix or their sales are not, it may be time to invite them to find another location. 

Rates: 

Sales knowledge and occupancy cost ratio is imperative when determining the new rents. If the tenant is paying $25psf, and the new lease market is $28, but the tenant’s occupancy ratio is 4% and it’s a pizza guy, then you could present very comfortably and confidently an 8% occupancy ratio. Yes, that would double his rent and be much higher than the market rents in your center but He CAN afford it. Now would I do it? If you know me, you know I would, especially if I evaluated the rest of the market and knew they couldn’t relo anywhere else, or if they did it would cost a few hundred thousand to do so. Now maybe practically I’d only raise them to $40nnn but my major point is I WOULD NOT SEND A RENEWAL AT A 3% INCREASE! Would the tenant leave your center when he has an over-performing store for an increase of $1500 per month – I think not (even if it’s a 37% increase in rent!)

I would NOT do this with uses that have zero infrastructure and could relo very inexpensively. The infrastructure in the space makes it a very important factor with this process.

Multiple leases expiring at the same time

(developers read: please stagger lease terms on ground-up developments when possible) 

One time I literally had 14 leases expiring the same year in a Publix anchored center. Luckily we had done a great job collecting sales so I knew who was doing well and who was not. We started 12 months in advance and worked on the tenants who had significant infrastructure in their spaces. (All of the renewals were set to renew at market rents.) We renewed all of the medical users such as dentist, urgent care and optometrist first. Then we renewed the Italian restaurant, sub shop, and Chinese restaurants next. By the time it had come to 90 days before expiration, we had renewed 80% of the expiring tenants and had set precedent on the “market” rents. Two of the tenants who did not have significant infrastructure did relo for cheaper rents. But luckily we backfilled them quickly. 

Knowledge of market and sales is crucial when faced with multiple expirations at the same time. 

My last tip is:

Making sure you know what uses are doing well in your market and those that are not. Having coffee with your neighborhood leasing agents on a regular basis will help with this updated market knowledge. This will help when evaluating which concepts to keep and which to let go. 

 

Share

Blog Comments

More Posts

Treat Franchisees Like Mom-and-Pops

One of the biggest mistakes landlords make is assuming a franchise tenant is automatically a strong tenant. If it’s a franchisee opening their first location, they’re essentially a startup—and you should treat them exactly like a mom-and-pop. That means doing full due diligence before agreeing to any deal. First, I require a credit check on both spouses (check your state laws, but in many states a guarantee may not hold if both spouses aren’t included). I also request a personal financial statement, bank statements, and a breakdown of startup costs. If someone tells me they have $30,000 in cash but their bank statement shows $6,000, that’s a red flag—and I’m going to ask questions. Next, I look at cash versus debt. If a tenant has minimal savings and significant credit card debt, that’s a warning sign. Starting a business is expensive, and I want to know they have the financial runway to survive the early months. If it’s a startup, I also ask for a simple one-page business plan showing projected revenue and expenses—rent, utilities, payroll, insurance, marketing. I want to see that they’ve thought through the economics of their business. And if they’re asking for tenant improvement money, I

Read More

Stop Fighting Obstacles, Prospect Around Them

Every shopping center has challenges. Maybe you have an elbow space with no visibility. Maybe a space has limited parking. Maybe prospects think your rent is too high. The mistake many landlords make is trying to convince the wrong tenants to accept those obstacles. Instead, I remove the objection entirely. If I have an elbow space with poor visibility, I don’t spend time pitching it to tenants who rely on impulse traffic. That’s a waste of time. Instead, I canvas businesses that are already operating in elbow spaces in other centers – things like tutoring centers, therapy practices, staffing agencies, or specialty service users. Those tenants already understand the trade-off and won’t see it as a deal breaker. The same strategy applies to parking constraints. I once had a space where handicap spots were directly in front of the entrance, meaning there was effectively no regular parking. Most retailers hated it. But an orthopedic shoe store loved it because many of their customers had handicap permits. The obstacle became an advantage. Rent objections work the same way. If my rents are $30 per square foot, I’m not canvassing centers where rents are $20. I focus on areas where tenants are

Read More

Don’t Always Choose the Big Name Tenant

When you’re deciding between two tenants – a well-known franchise and a local operator – it’s easy to assume the bigger brand is the safer bet. But in my experience, that’s not always true. Many franchise rollouts look exciting at first. They have marketing budgets, strong branding, and lots of buzz. But a lot of those concepts are new, and not all of them survive. I’ve seen plenty of “hot” brands expand quickly, request large tenant improvement packages, and then struggle just a few years later. That’s why I always dig into the financial statements. Sometimes a franchisee with multiple locations looks impressive on the surface, but when you study the numbers closely, the picture changes. On the other hand, a local tenant with two or three successful locations may actually be the more stable operator. I once worked on a deal where the choice was between a major corporate restaurant and a local family-owned concept. My client – who happened to be a CPA and attorney – analyzed the financials and chose the local tenant. Twenty years later, that local restaurant is still operating successfully, while the corporate concept has closed many of its locations. Another factor is tenant

Read More

How to Interview Third-Party Leasing Brokers

If you’re hiring a third-party leasing broker for your shopping center, don’t just take the first pitch you hear. The right broker can accelerate your leasing velocity—but the wrong one can waste months. Start by interviewing three to five brokerage firms. Look around your market and see who has the most retail listings or the highest-profile properties. Then invite them to pitch your asset. One important rule: make sure the actual agent who will work on your property attends the meeting—not just the senior broker who wins the listing. During the interview, ask them to bring their deal sheet from the past 12–18 months. I want to see evidence. Did they close two deals or twenty? Then dig deeper—pick a deal and ask how it happened. Did they canvas the market? Did they cold call the tenant? Or did the deal come from a sign call? True prospectors will proudly tell you stories about chasing tenants for months before landing the deal. I also like to see how prepared they are. Ask them to come with a market study and a leasing strategy for your property. What rents do they think the space should command? Who are the target tenants?

Read More

Beth's Resources

Beth has established a reputation for “giving back” and creating a legacy of helping others. To support this mission, she offers a wealth of FREE resources for individuals in the retail leasing industry, whether you’re a newcomer or a seasoned professional. Her collection includes case studies from her nearly 40 years of experience, providing practical insights and guidance. With Beth’s resources, you’ll gain valuable tools to navigate the complexities of retail leasing and achieve your professional goals.

E-News

Subscribe to the Beth Azor e-news to stay up to date with commercial real estate trends, events, and expert advice.

We promise, no spam. Just great content.

E-News

Subscribe to the Beth Azor e-news to stay up to date with commercial real estate trends, events, and expert advice.

We promise, no spam. Just great content.