Don’t Rush to Vanilla Shell a Space

When a tenant moves out and leaves a space looking rough, many landlords immediately think: Let’s vanilla shell it. But before you spend thousands fixing up a space, slow down and test the market first.

My rule? Give it about 90 days.

List the space exactly as it is and start showing it. If it’s a former Subway, call it a “former Subway.” Everyone knows what that looks like, and some prospects won’t care because they’re planning to gut it anyway. If a tenant is willing to take the space as-is, you may save yourself a lot of money. And if they want you to fix it? That’s a negotiation. You can always say, “If you want it cleaned up and renovated, the rent will be higher.”

Now, if you’ve shown the space 15–20 times and every prospect complains about the condition, that’s your signal. At that point, investing in repairs or creating a vanilla shell might make sense to help the deal get across the finish line.

This same strategy applies when you have multiple rough spaces. Don’t fix them all at once. If you have ten ugly vacancies, maybe you vanilla shell two—just enough to create spec spaces and test the market without overspending.

Rockstar Tip:
Always test demand before spending money. In leasing, sometimes the best improvement you can make is simply putting the space on the market and seeing who bites.

Share

Blog Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Posts

Renovate Without Disrupting Your Tenants

Renovating a shopping center can increase value, improve visibility, and boost tenant sales – but if you’re not careful, it can also disrupt the very businesses that pay your rent. When I started a major renovation on one of my centers, one of the first things I focused on was who would actually be running the job day-to-day. Not just the general contractor – but the superintendent on site every day. This person will interact with your tenants constantly, so customer service matters just as much as construction experience. Remember: you’re renovating an operating business environment. Your tenants are open, serving customers, and trying to make money. The last thing they need is chaos. Here are a few Rockstar strategies I use during renovations: Renovations are also a great opportunity to renegotiate lease terms. If you’re helping tenants upgrade signage or improving the property, you may be able to trade for things like removing outdated options or improving lease terms. Rockstar Tip: A renovation should increase value for both you and your tenants. Plan every step around one goal: improve the property without hurting tenant business.

Read More

Use Holiday Pop-Ups to Turn Vacancy Into Opportunity

If you have vacant space heading into the holidays and you know it won’t lease before January, don’t let it sit empty. Use that time to test seasonal pop-ups. I’ve done this many times in my centers. The idea is simple: offer a retailer a short-term opportunity – typically November through December (sometimes longer) to test the market. I’ll often offer the space free for a few months, as long as the tenant covers utilities, provides a security deposit, and takes the space as-is. They bring their merchandise and staff, and we both see what happens. The best candidates for holiday pop-ups are destination retailers with merchandise: toy stores, sneaker shops, sports apparel, tennis gear, hobby stores, or seasonal concepts. These businesses can generate strong holiday sales and benefit from a temporary location with built-in traffic. Pop-ups aren’t just about filling empty space – they’re about testing future tenants. Two of my long-term tenants actually started as pop-ups. One expanded multiple times and now occupies thousands of square feet in my center. Even if the pop-up doesn’t become a permanent tenant, you still win. The space is activated, new customers are introduced to the center, and your property feels vibrant

Read More

Get Involved in the Community Where Your Center Is

If you own a shopping center but don’t live in that city, you still need to be deeply involved in the local community. Leasing isn’t just about brokers and listing platforms – it’s about relationships. When you own one, two, or even a handful of centers, I strongly recommend visiting them regularly. Ideally, monthly. Walk the property, drive the surrounding market, and make sure you’re visible in the community. If you truly can’t do that yourself, assign someone who can – your leasing agent, property manager, or a trusted local representative. One of the best things you can do is join the local Chamber of Commerce and get to know the economic development director in that city. These relationships can generate leads and help solve problems. I’ve had deals come directly from chamber meetings, and I’ve had permitting issues resolved quickly simply because I knew the right person to call. When you attend chamber events, don’t just say you have vacancies. Be specific. Instead of saying, “I have space available,” say, “I have a former hair salon space that would be perfect for a barber,” or “I’m looking for a small insurance or real estate office.” Specific requests stick in

Read More

Treat Franchisees Like Mom-and-Pops

One of the biggest mistakes landlords make is assuming a franchise tenant is automatically a strong tenant. If it’s a franchisee opening their first location, they’re essentially a startup—and you should treat them exactly like a mom-and-pop. That means doing full due diligence before agreeing to any deal. First, I require a credit check on both spouses (check your state laws, but in many states a guarantee may not hold if both spouses aren’t included). I also request a personal financial statement, bank statements, and a breakdown of startup costs. If someone tells me they have $30,000 in cash but their bank statement shows $6,000, that’s a red flag—and I’m going to ask questions. Next, I look at cash versus debt. If a tenant has minimal savings and significant credit card debt, that’s a warning sign. Starting a business is expensive, and I want to know they have the financial runway to survive the early months. If it’s a startup, I also ask for a simple one-page business plan showing projected revenue and expenses—rent, utilities, payroll, insurance, marketing. I want to see that they’ve thought through the economics of their business. And if they’re asking for tenant improvement money, I

Read More

Beth's Resources

Beth has established a reputation for “giving back” and creating a legacy of helping others. To support this mission, she offers a wealth of FREE resources for individuals in the retail leasing industry, whether you’re a newcomer or a seasoned professional. Her collection includes case studies from her nearly 40 years of experience, providing practical insights and guidance. With Beth’s resources, you’ll gain valuable tools to navigate the complexities of retail leasing and achieve your professional goals.

E-News

Subscribe to the Beth Azor e-news to stay up to date with commercial real estate trends, events, and expert advice.

We promise, no spam. Just great content.

E-News

Subscribe to the Beth Azor e-news to stay up to date with commercial real estate trends, events, and expert advice.

We promise, no spam. Just great content.